Perplessità: 2.0 o 3.0?

Discussione in 'BMW Z4 E85/E86' iniziata da Deus ex machina, 31 Luglio 2009.

  1. Luigi 123d

    Luigi 123d Presidente Onorario BMW

    5.546
    119
    3 Dicembre 2007
    Reputazione:
    4.613
    Boxster S 981
    L'ho letto sul forum dei 370zisti e sono loro stessi a sostenerlo, ti posterò qualche stralcio...
     
  2. carloush

    carloush Amministratore Delegato BMW

    3.732
    125
    16 Maggio 2003
    Reputazione:
    5.196
    Audi S3, Z4 3.0i, MB E420, 147 GTA
    ok, ci credo.
    Andrò a provarla x scrupolo.. :D così non la compro :D
     
  3. Luigi 123d

    Luigi 123d Presidente Onorario BMW

    5.546
    119
    3 Dicembre 2007
    Reputazione:
    4.613
    Boxster S 981
    I have a 6MT and the whole car vibrates and almost feels like its going to rip apart at any moment lol (slight exageration) at high rpms. You really do feel it in the floor, steerng wheel, shifter...even the seat to some extent.
    Our car is very rough at high RPM's...I've been in a few cars that should be rougher per se, but are smooth as silk compared to this. Nissan lost points in the refinement department with this engine...

    everything, its gotta a very coarse feeling to it. Everything vibrates and sounds like its not supposed to be revving that high. Its something I've learned to live with, but it should not be this way. I wonder if its an engine mounts thing....

    A similar ammount of vibration is transmitted back through the steering, pedals and shifter, but for me, it's mostly the noise.

    A lot of reviews I've read concerning the VQ engine say the same thing. It's not isolated to our car, it's the VQ in general. It is rougher than other engines and I would love for it to be smoother but you do get used to it.

    Likely this has to more to do with the natural imbalance of the V6, which has been exacerbated as they stroked the original VQ engine design more and more. Another engine recently revised with a longer stroke and VVEL is the VK50DE. How harsh is the VK50 in the FX50 at high rpms?
    Edit: After finding Edmunds review, they stated that the VK50, 'much like VQ35/37 this V8 isn't quiet or smooth @ high RPM.' So we can rule that it's either the longer stroke, the VVEL or both.
     
  4. carloush

    carloush Amministratore Delegato BMW

    3.732
    125
    16 Maggio 2003
    Reputazione:
    5.196
    Audi S3, Z4 3.0i, MB E420, 147 GTA
    non vorrei però che fosse una..su quante? può avere un problema la sua,non credo che tutte vibrino come Mulinex...
    la Infinity coupè che ha lo stesso motore non mi pare abbia questi problemi.
    cerco in giro..

    Cmq io ho avuto svariati V6..Alfa, Mercedes etc..ma nessuno ha mai avuto una sola vibrazione o sussulto...MAI
     
  5. fabiocarc

    fabiocarc Secondo Pilota

    524
    17
    5 Dicembre 2008
    Reputazione:
    295
    BMW320d F31
    a fronte d diversi pareri vale solo il provare x credere
     
  6. Luigi 123d

    Luigi 123d Presidente Onorario BMW

    5.546
    119
    3 Dicembre 2007
    Reputazione:
    4.613
    Boxster S 981
    dovrebbero contattarmi a me per un test drive

    vi faccio sapere ;)
     

Condividi questa Pagina